Mushroom Coffee vs Regular Cup Of Joe – Here Is What You Should Know
  • Home  / 
  • Diet & Nutrition
  •  /  Mushroom Coffee vs Regular Cup Of Joe – Here Is What You Should Know

Mushroom Coffee vs Regular Cup Of Joe – Here Is What You Should Know

By Jen Evansy / June 14, 2019

Mushroom coffee might be the next biggest trend in superfoods but is this unique creation that much different from a regular cup of Joe?

Mushroom in the cup

I recently stumbled upon an alternative to my obsession that is so much healthier than the real stuff.

What sold me on this alternative coffee blend was it’s proximity to the real thing. This so-called alternative is Mushroom coffee.

It’s packed with antioxidants and anti-aging properties, and don’t even get me started on other benefits.

Check out the best ​blends here>>>

What is Mushroom Coffee?

combining mushrooms and coffee

Mushroom coffee is low caffeine, nutrient filled alternative to regular coffee. It is instant or ground coffee mixed with powdered medicinal fungi. Mushrooms’ earthy tang complements roasted coffee beans, giving it slightly nutty and earthy flavor and high levels of antioxidants and nutrients for better focus, productivity, and energy.

How Is It Made?

The process of making mushroom coffee involves drying and grounding consumable adaptogenic fungi into a fine powder. This powdered extract is then mixed with regular coffee. Most often used fungi to make mushroom powder include Lion's main, Cordyceps, Chaga and Reishi. These are chosen for their high antioxidant level and well-blending flavor.

What Are The Benefits Of Mushroom Coffee?

Drinking mushroom coffee will not only give you the benefits of the regular joe but you will also get all of the great benefits of consumable adaptogenic fungi.

Most notable benefits include:

  • Overall wellness
  • More balanced energy
  • Better focus
  • Antioxidant properties
  • Immune support
  • Reduced anxiety
  • Anti-aging benefits
  • Improved metabolism
  • Better sleep
  • Stress relief 
  • Promoting weight loss
  • Has neurotrophic and nootropic properties

In this video below, Aaron from Four Sigmatic explains all the benefits of the fungi that are included in their products.

Antioxidant Properties Of Edible Fungi

We are regularly exposed to a massive amount of pollution in our daily life. Whether it's from the air or other contaminants, we are routinely exposed to conditions that can cause cellular damage to our bodies over time. 

Mushrooms, however, protect us from this unavoidable damage that has sadly become part of our ordinary lives. Prolonged exposure to some of these free radicals can cause oxidative stress in our bodies, and that has been linked to all sort of degenerative conditions. 

antioxidant-rich fungi

Antioxidants are very powerful micronutrient that helps clear your body of free radicals.

There are various foods known to be antioxidant-rich. One of the most popular ones that we all know is green tea. It has been said to be packed with antioxidants and anti-aging properties.

Then, if green tea is packed with antioxidants, then, this coffee is absolutely overflowing with this stuff.

However, some mushrooms are more antioxidant-rich than others, but ultimately, they are all packed with the stuff. If I had to recommend some, it would have to be the Chaga and perhaps Reishi.

Chaga and Reishi are one of the most powerful natural antioxidants available. Rich in glutathione, ergothioneine, and adaptogens. These antioxidants help ward off diseases, fight damage by free radicals and can even have a positive effect on liver function.

Nootropic Edge Of This Coffee

Addition to lowering oxidative stress on your body and brain some mushrooms like Lion's Mane and Chaga have also been shown to give you a mighty boost of natural nootropics by strongly elevating acetylcholine levels in your body.

Also, containing unique compounds like erinacines and hericenones makes these mushrooms an exceptional nootropic and neurotrophic superfood.

Does Mushroom Coffee Have Caffeine?

caffeine content for energy

Caffeine found in this coffee is very similar to that of green tea. This can vary, but in general, one cup of mushroom brew contains an average of 40-50 mg of caffeine, which is equivalent to 1/2 cups of regular coffee or one cup of green tea.

This is really good because it cushions the prolonged side effects of consuming too much caffeine. You will be less prone to jitters and Insomnia. It also helps with restlessness and hyperactivity.

Potential For Weight Loss

Before and after weight loss

This might be the most alluring of all the advantages of this earthy coffee blend.

Coupled with the right diet, it could be one of the most essential beverages on your menu. Being part of a balanced diet that already promotes weight loss, this brew can help boost your metabolism and is also low in carbs, fat content and supports glycemic balance.

There are specific properties present in most adaptogenic mushrooms that result steadily boost energy consumption with consistent usage. These properties cause your body to consume more energy and break down fat deposits.

Assuming that you are already on a calorie deficit diet plan and live an active lifestyle, this brew can certainly give you an extra edge and nudge you closer to your weight loss goals

What Fungi Are Used In The Mix?

reishi fungi and cup of coffee

The Reishi mushroom also named as Lingzhi and Ganoderma Lucidum with kidney-shaped reddish cap.

There is an assortment of mushrooms that have been packed into this product for it to be so multi-faceted and effective. As mentioned above, the most popular ones are chaga, cordyceps, and reishi.

To pick the most important ones, I have narrow the list down to just a handful that has been used for centuries in traditional Chinese medicine, dating back to 600 A.D.

  • Lingzhi (Ganoderma lucidum)
  • Chaga (Inonotus obliquus)
  • Mitake (Grifola frondosa
  • Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum)
  • Turkey Tail (Trametes Versicolor)
  • Coliolus (Trametes versicolor)
  • Cordyceps (Ophiocordyceps sinensis)
  • Shitake (Lentinula edodes)
  • Lion’s Mane (Hericium erinaceus)
  • Agarikon (Laricifomes officinalis)

These are just a handful of mushrooms used in this earthy beverage that many have become to love so much.

Regular vs. Mushroom Coffee - Which One Is Better?

Tasting coffee

Observing the tastes and aromas of brewed coffee.

I think I have been building up to this particular question for quite some time now. It’s the ultimate question. Which is better: the new mushroom coffee, or the regular old cup of joe.

Mushroom Coffee is different in a few ways:

  1. The most apparent is that it contains mushrooms! (It does contain actual coffee as well)
  2. It contains only half the caffeine than regular coffee.
  3. Contains lot more nutrients and antioxidants.
  4. As many more additional benefits.
  5. Has an earthy, nutty, and slightly bitter herbal taste.

I would definitely recommend giving it a try and see how you like it. I personally have swapped my regular cuppa completely for this new mix.

Since I am not a big coffee drinker anyway, I just have one cup in the morning to start my day off right.

However, if you are a big coffee drinker you don't have to switch completely as I did. Having one or two cups a day is sufficient for extra nutrients and an antioxidant boost for a day. Perhaps right before you need to concentrate during study or work is a great time to drink it. 

Which One Tastes Better?

Mushroom coffee could be the answer for those who are looking for a healthy alternative to a regular cup of Joe. But can this earthy tasting brew convert a regular coffee drinker?

Click to Tweet

Although Mushroom coffee has a clear advantage on the nutrients front, a regular cup of Joe has it beat in the taste department.

Most people don’t mind being very earthy and zen, but when it requires chugging an earthy tasting cup of coffee every day for a month, their devotion to the lifestyle will be no doubt tested.

Regular coffee has been around for quite some time, and the coffee community has really done a number on it. There are hundreds of recipes and thousands of toppings, it’s almost impossible to have a bad cup of coffee.

Mushroom coffee, on the other hand, is more of an acquired taste, and it has minimal taste options. Sure there are innovative and tasty recipes from trusted sources like Four Sigmatic, but most of them require some skill.

And you cannot just go to your local coffee shop and order some. It is possible to have something great tasting out from the carton, but there aren’t a lot of these ones. And even if there are, they don’t taste outstanding. Even with added coconut sugar or stevia added to the mix, you cannot totally get the earthiness out.

Which One Is Cheaper?

Depends on what quality or brand you are looking for. The average coffee producer makes their products reasonably cheap and affordable, whereas the mushroom coffee is slightly above that price or sometimes double that. A double pack, expressos style ground coffee from Café Bustelo, is about $16, whereas, a 30 saches of Four Sigmatic Coffee mix is about $34. 

How To Prepare Mushroom Coffee

four sigmatic making instructions

Brewing instructions for Four Sigmatic Lion's Mane and Chaga coffee mix. 

If you are a black coffee person, then making a cup shouldn’t be too difficult. All you need is some hot water and a sachet of your favorite coffee brand. You can guess the rest.

If you are into something sweeter then you’ll have to do a little bit of mixing and blending but nothing too complicated. A short trip to YouTube should help you make a cup of Mushroom Mocha or anything else that catches your fancy.

Picking The Best Mix

Since Mushroom coffees aren’t as widespread as their counterpart, there are only a handful, reliable brands that you can really trust. It's not that there aren’t other great brands out there, it's just that I wholly recommend them because I have not used them like I have these ones.

Four Sigmatic Organic Coffee With Chaga And Cordyceps

They’re the best out there, and anyone who has quite the sweet tooth has heard of them. They are also known for their Mushroom mixtures and excellent customer service. I would recommend this brand to anyone just starting out.

PureShrooms Organic Mushroom Coffee With Lion's Mane

This one is a slightly cheaper alternative to the previous one. This is by no means inferior to Four Sigmatic, but in my opinion, it just doesn't taste as good. However, they do have quite the flavor bank, and their recipes are mostly tailored for weight loss.

Although it's not the tastiest alternative to a nearly perfect Four Sigmatic, its perks have made it the obvious choice for anyone that is looking to curb the side effect of drinking coffee without altogether quitting it.


It contains just enough caffeine to keep you going and not to mention that it is packed with all sorts of antioxidant and nourishment. And as I said, it is a bit cheaper and comes with possible weight loss option.


All in all, this beverage is a strong second choice. It doesn’t really matter whether you’re looking to live longer or lose weight, it’s a practical alternative to the real thing, and it is a beverage in its own right.

Four Sigmatic Organic Coffee With Chaga And Cordyceps

They’re the best out there, and anyone who has quite the sweet tooth has heard of them. They are also known for their Mushroom mixtures and excellent customer service. I would recommend this brand to anyone just starting out.

PureShrooms Organic Coffee With Lion's Mane Mushroom

This one is slightly cheaper alternative to the previous one. This is by no means inferior to Four Sigmatic, but in my opinion it just don’t taste as good. However, they do have quite the flavor bank, and their recipes are mostly tailored for weight loss.

Although it's not the tastiest alternative, in my opinion, to a nearly perfect Four Sigmatic, its perks have made it the obvious choice for anyone that is looking to curb the side effect of drinking coffee without altogether quitting it.


It contains just enough caffeine to keep you going and not to mention that it is packed with all sorts of antioxidant and nourishment. And as I said, it is bit cheaper, and comes with possible weight loss option.


All in all, this beverage is a strong second choice. It doesn’t really matter whether you’re looking to live longer or lose weight, it’s a practical alternative to the real thing, and it is a beverage in its own right.

Related Posts
About the author

Jen Evansy

Nutritionists, researchers, and writers, interested in everything healthy-living related. Helping you identify the best diets, learn about food and nutrition, to help you live happier, longer and stronger.


>